CraftJack vs Angi Leads: Honest 2026 Comparison for Roofers

CraftJack sells itself as the Angi alternative for contractors, with lower lead prices and faster delivery. For roofers, is it actually better? Short answer: marginally, and only in some scenarios.

CraftJack for roofers

• Cost per lead: $15 to $70 for roofing
• Lead delivery: text and email within 90 seconds of form fill
• Exclusivity: shared with 3 to 8 contractors (sometimes fewer than Angi)
• Discount for fast response: yes, up to 30 percent off if you call within 30 minutes

Angi Leads for roofers

• Cost per lead: $30 to $120 for roofing
• Lead delivery: platform notification, self serve
• Exclusivity: shared with 3 to 8 contractors
• Discount for fast response: no

Verdict

CraftJack is cheaper per lead but lead quality is generally worse. Angi has slightly better intent because homeowners actively searched a household brand. Both hover in the same cost per signed job range for roofers.

If you are going to run a shared marketplace at all, CraftJack usually beats Angi for smaller roofing companies who can respond in under 5 minutes. Angi wins for larger ops with a dispatcher answering marketplace pings all day.